The First Production V-Twin Indian: Setting the Record Straight

12 Mar

The scruffy blue motorcycle fitted with two gas tanks and a tandem seat stopped me in my tracks. Standing in the Wheels Through Time Museum in Maggie Valley, NC the realization dawned that I was looking at a piece of nearly forgotten history.

The prototype Hedstrom V-twin engine made its first appearance on August 5, 1904 at Newport Beach, RI on the first Indian V-twin. The 3hp V-twin was run in Orange, NJ on November 26 and raced at Ormond Beach in January 1905. One might consider this to be the origin of factory race programs being used for retail product development since the new 2.25hp single-cylinder engine, designed to power the new Indian Tri-car, was in production by November 1905.

Oscar Hedstrom and his new V-twin Indian at Ormond Beach, FL in January 1905.

Oscar Hedstrom and his new V-twin Indian at Ormond Beach, FL in January 1905.

The question as to when the Hendee Manufacturing Co. first offered a V-twin to the public is put to rest by a company sales brochure dated June 1906. “In presenting the Indian for the season of 1906 . . .” clearly states that the two motorcycles offered to retail customers were ’06 models. One of

Restored 1907 Indian racer.

Restored 1907 Indian racer.

these was the Indian Double Cylinder Racer rated at 4 hp, weight of 108 lbs. and priced at $350.

The new V-twin was patterned after the factory racer and didn’t have twist grips or fenders. The gas tank was a torpedo design that straddled the horizontal bar of the frame and not the camelback gas tank on the regular model. Other details were pedals with toe clips (just like those on modern bicycles), shorter handlebars, and the crank chain didn’t have a metal guard. It was fitted with a special split saddle positioned behind the seat tube.

The 1906 sales was titled: “Indian Motocycle, Which Renders Possible the Indian Tri-Car Indian Tricycle, Indian Tandem, Indian Triplet, and the Indian Van. Substantially Six Vehicles In One.” These six variations of the 1906 Indian were based on two attachments, a rear tandem seat and a chassis that replaced the front wheel of the motorcycle with a frame having two parallel, steerable front wheels.

The tandem attachment was introduced in 1904.  It was an extended crossbar fitted with fixed handlebars, a Brooks saddle, and a split brace that was bolted to the rear axle of the motorcycle. The tandem was offered as an accessory for $15.00 – a bargain considering that the Brooks spring suspension saddle sold for $8.00.

Several motorcycle companies offered tandem attachments.

Several motorcycle companies offered tandem attachments.

1907 Indian tri-car.

1907 Indian tri-car.

The tri-car was extensively tested in 1905, including competing in the F.A.M. (Federation of American Motorcyclists) endurance contest. Carrying two passengers, the Indian Tri-Car completed the run from New York to Waltham, AM in 16 hours and 20 minutes. In another competition held by the Brooklyn Motocycle Club, the Indian Triplet (Tri-Car with the tandem attachment) carried three passengers weighing a total of 430 pounds and completed the roundtrip course from Brooklyn to Southampton on Long Island in less than 11 hours of riding time. All this on a motorcycle with a single-cylinder 2¼ hp engine!

Some of the historical confusion regarding the year Hendee Mfg. Co. first introduced their V-twin results from the introduction of 1907 models in September of 1906. The standard camel-back motorcycle with twist grips, Brooks saddle, and long handlebars was called the “Indian Roadster” and it was offered with either the improved 2¾ hp single cylinder- or a 3½ hp V-twin engine. According to the 1907 sales brochure, “This [Indian Twin-Cylinder Motocycle] model in practically all save the motor is a reproduction of the single-cylinder Indian. Its means of transmission and control and its equipment are identical with the latter. The twin cylinders are made of the same metals and are of the same dimensions as the other, but their doubling, of course, increases the capacity of the engine to 4 horse-power . . . .” A couple of the first 1907 V-twin Roadsters to be manufactured were shipped to California in July, enabling George Holden and Louis Mueller to begin their record-breaking transcontinental trek from San Francisco to New York on August 10th.

1906 Indian V-twin clearly marked SN 123 with no "T."

1906 Indian V-twin clearly marked SN 123 with no “T.”

Hendee manufactured 1,698 motorcycles in 1906. Surviving records don’t indicate how many of these were V-twins. However, records for the 1907 models show that serial numbers T100-T499 were V-twins and that 2,176 motorcycles sold that year. Two-cylinder engines with serial numbers not prefaced by “T” apparently were manufactured in 1906 even though they were Roadster models. The Hedstrom (Indian) engines had been built under license by the Aurora Automatic Machinery Company in Illinois since 1901, but the new 2¾ hp single- and twin-cylinder engines were manufactured at the new Indian factory on State St. in Springfield, MA in 1906. My investigations suggest that a new series of serial numbers was begun at this time.

For obvious reasons the higher powered V-twin became preferred by those fitting the $125 Tri-Car or Van attachments to their motorcycles. Most surviving antique photographs show these arrangements with V-twin engines. By 1908 the Tri-Car was produced in limited quantities and the twin-cylinder engine had been improved to deliver 5 hp, while that for the race version—which still had a torpedo gas tank–now produced 7 hp. The dusty blue motorcycle in the Wheels Through Time Museum is a 1908 model, a 5 hp V-twin fitted with a tandem attachment and both an optional torpedo gas tank on the crossbar and a camel tank on the rear fender. Fitted with an acetylene M tank and headlamp, I can only assume that this particular motorcycle was setup for one of the popular cross-country endurance contests of the era, but its secret of its origins probably lies hidden in a long-forgotten newspaper story filed in the special archives of some local public library.

There can be little argument that the first U.S. production V-twin motorcycles were made by Glenn Curtis under the Hercules brand name, not by Hendee Mfg. Company. On Memorial Day in 1903 Glenn Curtiss showed up at the New York Motorcycle Club’s first hill climb event with his new V-twin motorcycle. He not only won the hill climb but later set a land speed record on this machine in Yonkers, NY. That same year, Thomas Baldwin ordered a Curtiss V-twin engine and installed it in a dirigible to make the first successful powered flight in 1904. Sold under the brand name Hercules, Curtiss was selling street versions—with an optional tandem seat—of his 5-hp V-twin by 1904 and the American Motorcycle Co. (Marsh-Metz) was offering a 4 hp, 1,000cc V-twin in 1906. Least one forgets: Curtiss made his famous run on Ormond Beach with his V-8 engine in January of 1907.

Mr. & Mrs. Glen Curtiss on a production Hercules V-twin with tandem attachment in 1904.

Mr. & Mrs. Glen Curtiss on a production Hercules V-twin with tandem attachment in 1904.

Nor can American inventors claim to have invented the V-twin since these motorcycles first appeared in Europe in 1902 with the Griffon fitted with a modified De Dion engine. By 1906 15 different European motorcycle brands offered V-twins. Indian was not the first manufacturer of V-twin engines and Harley-Davidson was a relative latecomer to the market, but these two iconic marquees would be responsible for inextricably associating the V-twin engine as being an American motorcycle.

Oscar Hedstrom with an experimental V-twin about 1907.

Oscar Hedstrom with an experimental V-twin about 1907.

4 Responses to “The First Production V-Twin Indian: Setting the Record Straight”

  1. David Banks October 20, 2020 at 5:49 am #

    My understanding was that the pre-1906 Indian twins (before the ‘T’) were built by Aurora as were the singles. Derkum is seated on one in a 1908 picture in Steve Wright’s American Racer. One survivor apparently exists in California. The ‘Thor’ top end is one distinction, also the timing cover. Maybe there is some maker overlap.

    • touringroads October 20, 2020 at 2:06 pm #

      The Indian V-twins ( model year 1907 with production in the new factory begun in August 1906)

      • David Banks October 20, 2020 at 5:31 pm #

        That would make the Aurora made Indian twins very scarce. I wonder how they were numbered?

  2. David Banks October 20, 2020 at 9:55 pm #

    Of course in my earlier comment I meant to write pre-1907. What are your thoughts on the fact Indian often advertised models that were not yet available to the public ‘to test the demand’? Possible examples: 1906 twin racers, 1908 1000cc twins, 1909 1000cc twins. Also have you ever heard of an example of a surviving production 1910 1000cc twin? I very much appreciate your thoughts.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: